• Free Consultation
  • Free IP Audit
  • International Brand Protection
  • About
  • Careers
  • Global IP Blogs
  • Contact
  • Login
Lexprotector.com
+1 – 888 890 6411 [email protected]
  • Trademark
    • Trademark Search
      • Indian Trademark Search
      • USA Trademark Search
      • EU Trademark Search
      • UK Trademark Search
      • Canada Trademark Search
      • Australia Trademark Search
      • New Zealand Trademark Search
    • Trademark Registration
      • Indian Trademark Registration
      • USA Trademark Registration
      • EU Trademark Registration
      • UK Trademark Registration
      • Canada Trademark Registration
      • Australia Trademark Registration
      • New Zealand Trademark Registration
    • Trademark Monitoring
      • Indian Trademark Monitoring
      • USA Trademark Monitoring
      • EU Trademark Monitoring
      • UK Trademark Monitoring
      • Canada Trademark Monitoring
      • Australia Trademark Monitoring
      • New Zealand Trademark Monitoring
    • Trademark Consultation
      • Indian Trademark Consultation
      • USA Trademark Consultation
      • EU Trademark Consultation
      • UK Trademark Consultation
      • Canada Trademark Consultation
      • Australia Trademark Consultation
      • New Zealand Trademark Consultation
  • Patent
    • Patent Search
      • Prior Art Search
      • Freedom to Operate Search
      • Utility Patent Search
    • Patent Drafting
      • USA Provisional Patent Drafting
      • USA Non-Provisional Patent Drafting
      • Indian Provisional Patent Drafting
      • Indian Complete Specification Drafting
    • Patent Filing
      • USA Provisional Patent Filing
      • USA Non-Provisional Patent Filing
      • Indian Provisional Patent Filing
      • Indian Complete Specification Filing
    • Patent Consultation
      • Patent Consultation
      • Utility Patent Consultation
      • Design Patent Consultation
    • Design Patent
      • Design Patent Search
      • EU Design Patent Filing
      • USA Design Patent Filing
      • India Industrial Design Filing
  • IP Enforcement
    • Violation Search
    • DMCA Takedown Notice
    • IP Enforcement
      • Copyright Enforcement
      • Trademark Enforcement
      • Utility Patent Enforcement
      • Design Patent Enforcement
    • Amazon Brand Registration
    • Copyright Registration
      • Indian Copyright Registration
      • USA Copyright Registration
  • IP Management
    • IP Due Diligence
    • IP Auditing
    • IP Valuation
    • IP Licensing
    • IP Consultation
+1 – 888 890 6411 [email protected]

Navigating the Legal Maze: AI, IP Rights, and the Quest for Clarity

  • Older
  • Newer

Navigating the Legal Maze: AI, IP Rights, and the Quest for Clarity

Lately, a bunch of countries, like the USA and the UK, have made it clear that their local laws don’t really recognize the outputs of artificial intelligence (AI). Figuring out what exactly qualifies as ‘autonomous inventions’ versus ‘AI aided inventions’ is a bit of a head-scratcher, especially since there’s no official technical definition for it. With the advent of technology, AI can be used either as a tool to produce a creative output or it creates independent outputs through self-learning algorithms without any human intervention.

Now, when AI is merely used as a tool, it’s crucial to figure out how the extent of human link and intervention used to produce the given output on which IP rights are demanded. Just hitting a button or providing in a few basic instructions isn’t enough to give exclusive IP rights on the human author. It is important to determine such questions to ensure that the very purpose of IP rights is not defeated by conferring protection to humans on works where no creative effort, skill, or judgment has been used.

AI as a tool may give rise to legal ambiguity in terms of determining inventorship. IP law generally does not differentiate between ideas that arise solely from the inventor’s thoughts and those that are created through problem-solving methods and tools. For instance, if a painter uses a paint brush for creating a painting, he would not be denied copyright for the use of the brush as a tool.

But how is this justified? AI systems differ from humans in terms of their capacity and capability to process data. These are not merely tools, but ‘self-learning’ tools capable of producing original works. Thus, even the use of AI as a tool is problematic for determining authorship/ownership status owing to the jurisprudence of Creativity, Sweat & Brow, Labour, and Personality theories.

At the current state of technology, neither the jurisprudential theories of IP nor the level of ‘self-learning’ mechanisms of these systems justify IP rights. Given the current predictions of AI designers regarding the uncertain and distant arrival of Artificial General Intelligence, it seems more advantageous to shift focus towards more relevant matters concerning intellectual property (IP) law in relation to AI techniques. Plus, let’s take a good look at what role IP law is really playing in boosting AI innovation.

  • Categories
    IP Rights
  • Author

    Foram Shah

Contents

Get Monthly

Global IP Updates

Join our community of over 10,000 subscribers and receive monthly updates on the latest IPR news and changes from around the globe.

Leave a Reply Cancel Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts

Tax Implications of Cross-Border Assignments

Safeguarding Biometric Data as Intellectual Property in the Age of AI

DeepSeek AI ’s Trademark Battle: A Legal Storm in the AI World

Subscribe Us

Quick Links

  • Utility Patent Search
  • Patent Drafting
  • Patent Consultation
  • Design Patent Search
  • Portfolio
  • Partner Portal Login
  • Global IP Blogs
  • Todays Trademark Blog
  • Todays Patent Blog

Services

  • USA Trademark Registration
  • UK Trademark Registration
  • EU Trademark Registration
  • Indian Trademark Registration
  • Australia Trademark Registration
  • New Zealand Trademark Registration
  • Canada Trademark Registration
  • Copyright Registration
  • DMCA Takedown Notice

Contact Us

  • [email protected]
  • +1 – 888 890 6411 +1 (833) 535-9144 (FAX)
  • 16192 Coastal Highway, Lewes, Delaware 19958, USA

In India - Bhubaneswar | Ahmedabad | Bangalore | Guwahati | Mumbai

International - United States | United Kingdom | Australia | Estonia

© 2012-25 LEX PROTECTOR. All rights reserved

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • DMCA

Quick Navigating the Legal Maze: AI, IP Rights, and the Quest for Clarity