[email protected]
  • About
  • Careers
  • Portfolio
  • Global IP Blogs
  • Contact
  • Login
Lexprotector.com
  • Trademark
    • Trademark Search
      • Indian Trademark Search
      • USA Trademark Search
      • EU Trademark Search
      • UK Trademark Search
      • Canada Trademark Search
      • Australia Trademark Search
      • New Zealand Trademark Search
    • Trademark Registration
      • Indian Trademark Registration
      • USA Trademark Registration
      • EU Trademark Registration
      • UK Trademark Registration
      • Canada Trademark Registration
      • Australia Trademark Registration
      • New Zealand Trademark Registration
    • Trademark Monitoring
      • Indian Trademark Monitoring
      • USA Trademark Monitoring
      • EU Trademark Monitoring
    • Trademark Consultation
      • Indian Trademark Consultation
      • USA Trademark Consultation
      • EU Trademark Consultation
  • Patent
    • Patent Search
      • Prior Art Search
      • Freedom to Operate Search
      • Utility Patent Search
    • Patent Drafting
      • USA Provisional Patent Drafting
      • USA Non-Provisional Patent Drafting
      • Indian Provisional Patent Drafting
      • Indian Complete Specification Drafting
    • Patent Filing
      • USA Provisional Patent Filing
      • USA Non-Provisional Patent Filing
      • Indian Provisional Patent Filing
      • Indian Complete Specification Filing
    • Patent Consultation
      • Patent Consultation
      • Utility Patent Consultation
      • Design Patent Consultation
    • Design Patent
      • Design Patent Search
      • EU Design Patent Filing
      • USA Design Patent Filing
      • India Industrial Design Filing
  • IP Enforcement and Copyright
    • Violation Search
    • DMCA Takedown Notice
    • IP Enforcement
      • Copyright Enforcement
      • Trademark Enforcement
      • Utility Patent Enforcement
      • Design Patent Enforcement
    • Amazon Brand Registration
    • Copyright Registration
      • Indian Copyright Registration
      • USA Copyright Registration
  • IP Management
    • IP Due Diligence
    • IP Auditing
    • IP Valuation
    • IP Licensing
    • IP Consultation
Call Us

Brand Protection and John Doe Orders; in the light of Amway’s case

  • Older
  • Newer

Brand Protection and John Doe Orders; in the light of Amway’s case

By: Rutambhara Nayak

With the release of a movie or a series on a legit streaming service, pops up several other illegal means to access those either through free downloads or at a cheaper subscription price. Same is the case with any protected material over the internet as there is always an alternate source available, upon use of which the intellectual investment of the original owner is discredited. With the overuse of ever-evolving technology and the nature of trade and business assuming international or global criteria, IP has become a powerful commercial asset though it is an intangible property.

John Doe orders were adopted to tackle with such kind of threats coming from unknown sources. The unlimited space of digital media and Intellectual Property laws being territorial in nature makes it difficult for the protection of exclusive rights in such a space. It becomes easier for unknown and anonymous persons to infringe the protected works and remain untraced. Hence, John Doe orders came to the rescue.

 

The origin of John Doe Orders dates back to the reign of King Edward III of British empire. It was inculcated in India in 2002 by an order passed in the landmark Taj Television Case against unknown cable operators who were illegally airing a certain sporting event covered by Ten Sports channel which had acquired an exclusive right to air it. In India, John Doe orders are known as Ashok Kumar orders and are of the nature of ex-parte interim injunctions.

 

Recently, Amway Corporation (now known as Alticor Inc.) a direct selling company operating in consumer health-care space obtained “John Doe” order from the Delhi High Court against the stockists who were selling their products through unauthorized channels.

The suit was brought against medical shops in Bhagirath Palace, Chandni Chowk. It was contended that such sale was being carried out in violation of the Central government’s Direct Selling Guidelines, 2016. The unauthorized party after removing the unique codes placed on the lid of the product and in some case even without issuing invoice and not providing the benefit of Return/Refund Policy were selling their products which was very much likely to harm their reputation.

This was found out by an investigation where the investigators were offered goods, but the defendants failed to issue any receipt for the purchase and also could not explain as to how such goods were received by them. Four Advocates were also appointed as local commissioners to conduct inspections in Bhagirath Palace and find out more about the errant sellers.

While the John Doe Order is a weapon in the hands of IPR enthusiasts, enforcement is still a tricky issue as it gives way to the infringers to play with the loopholes of law. The Court with this order has given boost to the direct selling companies which is a growing industry in India.

Although upon a bonafide claim of the plaintiffs, they have a right to have the identity revealed for the purpose of bringing action but how far such an order can be executed is the matter in issue. Hence, John Doe order is a strong shield for the aggrieved party but subject to its implementation.

For more information on IPR, Visit Lex Protector 

 

  • Categories
    International IPR
  • Author

    Lex Protector

Leave a Reply Cancel Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts

Who will be benefited by the agreement between the 29 major drug companies and INTERPOL against the counterfeit drug?

Emonster Haunts Apple for Trademark Violation

An Analysis of Intellectual Property of Disney and their use in special events

Subscribe Us

Quick Links

  • Portfolio
  • Global IP Blogs
  • About Us
  • Careers

Services

  • Trademark
  • Patent
  • IP Enforcement and Copyright
  • IP Management

Contact Us

  • [email protected]
  • +1 – 888 890 6411 +1 (833) 535-9144 (FAX)
  • 16192 Coastal Highway, Lewes, Delaware 19958, USA

In India - Bhubaneswar | Ahmedabad | Bangalore | Guwahati | Mumbai

International - United States | United Kingdom | Australia | Estonia

© 2012-23 LEX PROTECTOR. All rights reserved

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • DMCA

Quick Brand Protection and John Doe Orders; in the light of Amway’s case